Sat Jul 5, 2008
Free Subscription

  
   
Search the Journal
 

 
Advanced Search

Journal Links
 

Return to Front Page
Table of Contents
About Us
Editorial Board
Call to Papers
Contact Us
Policies

 
My Account
 
Username:
Password:


Register - FREE
Account Help
 

No Insanity Defense, No Miranda Question
Volume 3, Issue 3 -- Published: Sunday, Jan 31, 1999 -- Last Updated: Monday, Mar 11, 2002

Email to a colleague Comment on article Bookmark article Copyright & reprint info

 by: Marc Sperber, J.D.
A murder defendant who withdraws his defense of mental disease or defect prior to trial cannot claim he was not competent to waive his Miranda rights. The defendant, under the influence of drugs, was arrested and three days later confessed to the crimes of second-degree murder and possession of a controlled substance with intent to deliver. He wrote "yes" beside each statement in the waiver-of-rights document. A police officer present at the confession said that the defendant was down from the drugs and was completely coherent. The defendant even exercised his Miranda rights during the confession by saying, "I'm wanting to shut up."
After being examined for 30 days in the state mental hospital, the defendant was found to have amphetamine-induced psychotic disorder and incompetent to assist in his own defense. After a year's stay in a hospital, he was found competent to assist his attorneys and understand the proceedings against him.
The Supreme Court of Arkansas noted, "based on the totality of the circumstances, we conclude that the trial court's determination that appellant made a knowing and intelligent waiver of his Miranda rights was not clearly erroneous.... Further, we note that appellant withdrew his defense of mental disease or defect prior to trial, thereby eliminating the question of his sanity from the issues considered at trial."

Feedback: What do you have to say?  |  Help: Get expert assistance for your own case

Return to the front page of The Forensic Echo now!

Terms of Use   |   Privacy Statement
All Rights Reserved. Copyright © 1996-2003 The Forensic Panel