Sat Jul 5, 2008
Free Subscription

  
   
Search the Journal
 

 
Advanced Search

Journal Links
 

Return to Front Page
Table of Contents
About Us
Editorial Board
Call to Papers
Contact Us
Policies

 
My Account
 
Username:
Password:


Register - FREE
Account Help
 

Doc's Questionnaire Admitted in Sex Assault
Volume 1, Issue 12 -- Published: Friday, Oct 31, 1997 -- Last Updated: Monday, Mar 11, 2002

Email to a colleague Comment on article Bookmark article Copyright & reprint info

A sexual assault victim's answers to a questionnaire administered by the doctor when he examined her were admissible under the medical diagnosis exception to the hearsay rule.
The victim's ordeal was especially heinous. She was kidnapped at gunpoint and taken to her assailant's home, where he and his wife beat, raped, and sexually assaulted her overnight. She was locked in a closet, nude and tied with duct tape, cord and ace wraps. She escaped the next day by starting a fire in the closet and, while still inside the house, telephoned 911 for help.
She was taken to the hospital and examined approximately three hours after her rescue. The physician questioned her, using a "Sexual Assault Examination and Forensic Report Form." Her answers were admitted as testimony at trial. On appeal, the defense challenged the admissibility of the responses, arguing that the form was a hospital business record and the victim's statements were hearsay because she was not a part of the hospital's staff.
The Appeals Court rejected the distinction, noting that many of the victim's recorded statements were used for the purposes of medical diagnosis or treatment. While some of her statements were not used for this purpose, the defense failed to distinguish between the two. The Court declined to assume the obligation of sorting through the statements on the defendant's behalf.

Feedback: What do you have to say?  |  Help: Get expert assistance for your own case

Return to the front page of The Forensic Echo now!

Terms of Use   |   Privacy Statement
All Rights Reserved. Copyright © 1996-2003 The Forensic Panel